How to Choose the Right Hair Dye Shade for Gray Hair

Polar Instant Dye Shampoo in Light Brown, a softer shade for blending gray

The most common at-home coloring mistake isn't technique. It's picking a shade that's too dark. Gray hair takes color differently from pigmented hair, and a shade that looks right on the box can come out flat or harsh. Here's how to choose a shade that covers gray and still looks like you.

Rule 1: Start from your natural color, not your old color

Look at the hair near your scalp that isn't gray yet, or at the underside layers at the back. That's your natural level. Pick the shade closest to it. Your hair color at 25 is usually not the best guide now, because skin tone softens with age and very dark shades can look severe.

Rule 2: When in doubt, go lighter

If you're between two shades, choose the lighter one. Gray hair has no pigment of its own, so it often grabs color strongly and can end up darker than expected. A lighter shade also makes regrowth less obvious, because the contrast with new gray roots is smaller. It's easy to go a step darker next time. Going lighter after a too-dark result is much harder. If it does happen, see our tips for roots that came out too dark.

Rule 3: Match the shade to how much gray you have

  • A little gray (under about 25%): your natural shade usually works well.
  • About half gray: stay at your natural shade or one step lighter for a softer blend.
  • Mostly gray: a lighter shade usually looks more natural than a dark one, and roots show less as they grow.

Which Polar shade is for you?

Polar Instant Dye Shampoo comes in 5 shades:

  • Black: for naturally black or very dark hair. On beards, many people find Dark Brown looks more natural.
  • Dark Brown: the safest choice for most dark-haired people and most beards.
  • Light Brown: for medium to light brown hair, or for softer coverage when you have a lot of gray.
  • Purple and Red: fashion shades for a visible tint. On gray hair they show brighter; on dark hair they show as a subtle tone in the light.

A quick note on skin tone

Warm skin tones (golden or olive) usually suit warmer browns. Cool skin tones (pink or rosy) often look best with neutral or cooler shades. Either way, the lightness of the shade matters more than its tone, so get Rule 2 right first.

Before you color

  1. Do a patch test 24 hours before every use.
  2. If you're nervous about the shade, color a small hidden section first, like the hair behind your ear, and check it in daylight.
  3. Follow the timing on the label, then see our tips to make your color last longer.

General information only. Results vary by hair type, starting color and the amount of gray.